You're in the tattoo chair, and you've just made it through the linework. The outline is sharp and clean. Now, the artist switches their machine, and you brace yourself for the next phase: the shading. This leads to one of the most debated questions in any tattoo studio: does shading hurt more than the outline?
Ask any ten people with tattoos, and you'll likely get ten different answers. Some will swear the sharp lines were the worst part, while others will tell you the repetitive shading was unbearable. The truth is, it's not a simple yes or no. The "pain" from each is a very different sensation, and which one is "worse" often comes down to the individual, the placement, and the duration of the session.
This guide will break down the differences in sensation and help you understand what to expect from each stage of your tattoo.
The Sensation of the Outline (Lining)
-
What it feels like: The outline is the part of the tattoo process most people are familiar with. It is a sharp, precise, and often stinging pain. It's the classic "hot cat scratch" analogy. The artist is using a tight grouping of needles (a Round Liner) to create a single, crisp line, so the pain is very focused. This is the part that defines what getting a tattoo feels like for most first-timers.
-
Why it can be the "worst" part: For many, the initial shock of the needle and the sharp, biting nature of the linework is the most intense part of the experience.
The Sensation of Shading
-
What it feels like: Shading is a completely different kind of pain. It is generally less sharp, but more broad and abrasive. The artist is using a wider set of needles (a Magnum) to go back and forth over the same area, building up tones. The feeling is often described as a dull, burning, or rubbing sensation, similar to a bad sunburn being scraped.
-
Why it can be the "worst" part: While it's less sharp, shading can be more mentally grueling for a few key reasons:
-
It's Repetitive: The artist is working on the same patch of skin over and over, which becomes progressively more raw and tender.
-
It Happens Later: The shading comes after the outline, meaning your skin is already inflamed and your adrenaline has worn off. Your pain tolerance is naturally lower at this point.
-
It Takes Longer: How long does a tattoo take? The shading and coloring almost always take significantly longer than the linework, meaning you're enduring this sensation for a longer period.
-
The Verdict: So, Which is More Painful?
For most people, the consensus is that while the outline feels sharper and more intense in the moment, the shading process is often more difficult to endure due to the long duration and the raw, repetitive nature of the sensation. A painful tattoo experience is often defined by the long, grinding hours of shading.
The Ultimate Solution: Make the Debate Irrelevant
Why choose which part of the process has to be the most painful when you can make them both comfortable? A comprehensive pain management strategy is the best way to prepare for a tattoo and makes the "lining vs. shading" debate irrelevant.
-
Our No Pain Tattoo Numbing Cream is designed to deeply numb the skin before your session even starts. When applied correctly, it dramatically dulls both the sharp pain of the outline and the burning sensation of the shading, reducing both to a manageable pressure.
-
For those long sessions where the shading goes on for hours, our No Pain Tattoo Final Mile Gel™ can be applied by your artist mid-session to re-numb the area, making the most grueling part of the tattoo comfortable.
By using the complete No Pain Tattoo Numbing Products Bundle (Comfort Bundle), you don't have to worry about which part will hurt more. You can relax through the entire process, from the first line to the last bit of shading, confident that your artist can create a perfect piece of art on a calm, still canvas.